Segment · Episode 52
Bible vs Bible — Goliath
Jump to the in-depth discussion
- Elhanan son of Jair
- Goliath
- David
- +6
Elhanan son of Jair
Elhanan son of Jair is the figure named in 1 Chronicles 20:5 as the warrior who killed Lahmi, the brother of Goliath, while a parallel account in 2 Samuel 21:19 appears to preserve an earlier version in which Elhanan kills Goliath himself. He therefore sits at the center of debates about textual corruption, harmonization, and the development of the David tradition.
Redirected from: Elhanan
Why this topic matters
Elhanan son of Jair is one of the clearest examples of how later biblical writers and editors can reshape older traditions. When Dan and Dan discuss him, the issue is not just who killed Goliath, but how textual variants, scribal choices, and theological pressures can turn one remembered champion into another figure’s accomplishment.
Elhanan becomes a recurring touchpoint in discussions about contradiction, harmonization, and the growth of the David story. He becomes a compact case study in how the Bible preserves competing memories of the past and how later texts sometimes smooth those tensions rather than leaving them unresolved.
Where to start
Start here for the best in-depth listening on Elhanan son of Jair: featured segments, featured episodes, and the episode with the most mentions.
Quotes from the Data
“It seems like the killing of Goliath is being attributed to Elhanan.”
“What it seems happened is that 2nd Samuel 21 seems to preserve an alternative story, at least a brief mention of an alternative story, regarding the killing of Goliath. And then First Chronicles 20, which is being copied down much later, seems to recognize there's a problem here and so kind of massages the text a little bit to reconcile the problem.”
“The scholarly consensus is that there was a story about a dude named Elhanan who killed this giant named Goliath. And suddenly there's a five finger discount going on by whoever is responsible for the David history.”
“Likely the authors of Chronicles, who are writing centuries after whoever wrote this tradition as it's found in the book of 2 Samuel, are not happy—not comfortable with this idea since we already know who killed Goliath, and so they tweak the text just slightly in order to make it agree with the rest of the tradition.”
Top episodes
Ranked by mentions of Elhanan son of Jair across the transcript. Start with the top mention above, then keep going here.
All episodes
Every episode currently tagged with Elhanan son of Jair.